Monday, February 8, 2010

As a Restaurant, Hotel and Tourism major I am obviously interested in what the environment of that industry is and will be when I graduate. I have always found it interesting that although the kitchen is deemed the female's domain it is generally dominated by men in the public sphere. For my paper I would like to analyze the show Top Chef on Bravo because it is taken to be a representation of today's chefs. I have noticed however, in this and other cooking shows, that the majority of winners are men. There is also a wedding competition in one of the episodes that sparks emotion with some of the homosexual contestants that I think would be interesting to discuss.

I am critical of all reality shows because they claim to be a real life look at a specific topic but may not always be very responsible in doing so. While Top Chef definitely is not the worst offender of this I still think it is important to look at the way female chefs are represented versus male chefs as well as homosexual chefs versus heterosexual chefs.

Although I definitely still need to do some research, I am hoping to center my paper around the idea that Top Chef's heteronormative slant may portray a harmful representation of the industry to its viewers.

By doing this I hope to convince my readers to be more critical of all forms of media, especially "reality" shows but not just the trashy VH1 ones! These shows that are seemingly realistic still must be concerned with being entertaining over factual and completely truthful.

2 comments:

  1. I think this is a really interesting topic. I had never really thought about Top Chef this way before, but you brought up some really good points. I personally don't know a whole lot about cooking, either as a practice or as a career, so I would be really interesting in hearing what you find out. I've always assumed that this is what the industry is like, but I guess it has been without really taking into consideration that this may be an inaccurate representation. I also think it's really cool that you can tie it in to your major. I don't think you'll have any trouble getting 4-6 pages out of it.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Grace,

    I agree with Kelly; this is an interesting topic for your paper. First, the idea that there has only been one female winner of Top Chef seems to challenge the idea that women are typically better cooks ALTHOUGH, on the show there is a lot made of the fact that it is difficult for women to make it in the restaurant business - being a chef, it seems, is a job reserved for men.

    The idea of looking at the types of challenges the contestants have to compete will be an excellent way into examining representations of gender and sexuality on this show. There is almost always a competition dealing with a wedding (I think they cooked for Gail's wedding shower one year!) You asked an excellent question there: who gets included in those competitions, and who gets left out? On the other hand, being able to cook for a wedding, baby shower, etc., could be an aspect of being a chef that is important. I guess the question is: are there other competitions that the show could have created that might still get at the same challenges cooking for a wedding presents? I'm interested to see what you come up with as you explore your topic. ~Megan

    ReplyDelete